What if I don’t want to talk about it?

What Vulnerability in Therapy Looks Like, and Alternatives to Talk Therapy

I was recently chatting with an acquaintance about mental health, and an interesting question came up. The query was: “How do you do therapy if you don’t want to talk about what happened?” I suspect this is a more common thought than people admit, even though we are socially more open to talking about mental health and engaging in what most call “talk therapy.”  

In my experience and observation, the mental hurdle of going into an office and opening up to essentially a stranger is daunting. It requires a ton of vulnerability! So, let’s consider what appropriate vulnerability looks like when starting therapy. Then, for situations when talking is not a good fit, let’s explore a couple of talk therapy alternatives that focus more directly on the brain. 

What If I Don’t Want to Talk About It?

How vulnerable should therapy be?

Especially for those who haven’t experienced therapy before, it can be helpful to understand what the intake process looks like. Your first therapy session will likely involve discussing: 

  • A variety of assessment approaches, depending on the therapist 
  • What you came there to talk about 
  • Anything the therapist noted that they would like to ensure they fully understand (these topics can be sensitive) 

However, let’s be clear: this does not require you to share every detail of your life history if you are not ready. Honest answers to questions are important (they are necessary to keep you and the therapy room safe), but you can take your time getting comfortable. You are allowed to feel out who the person on the other side of the room is. You’re allowed to start with building rapport. That way, when you open a topic that feels overwhelming, you can focus on the safety of your relationship with your therapist, rather than the discomfort of sharing with a stranger.

Please be honest if you are in a crisis, but we can unpack the emotional tangle when you are ready. If building trust at your own pace is a new concept for you, this could even be a good starting point for your therapy journey. Trust-building could be the focus of your initial conversations as you are getting to know your provider. 

You get to say how much you say

If you are someone who struggles with power structures due to your history, therapy may seem particularly vulnerable.  It can be important to remember that a healthy therapist will support your autonomy as a client.  Generally speaking, you should:

  • Be an active participant in deciding the pace 
  • Know you have a choice whether you continue with that therapist
  • Have the ability to give feedback if an intervention is not benefiting you 

That being said, you should feel (in time) that this is someone who you would accept influence from.  If you find yourself questioning your therapist consistently, then it may be a good time to talk with your therapist about the source of those questions. It may be something you just need to process, or it may be that the therapist is not a good fit—and that is okay.   

When to Look Beyond Talk Therapy

You may be thinking, “Okay, so I don’t have to open Pandora’s box immediately. I have autonomy… but what if I shut down when I try to talk about it at all?”  This is part of why the therapy field has been consistently growing in the area of “brain-based interventions.”  These are alternatives to talk therapy that address healing on a deeper level. Typically, I toss EMDR, Brainspotting, Neurofeedback, and (sometimes) other interventions like Somatic Experiencing and Hypnotherapy into this conversation.

For this post, I’ll speak primarily to Brainspotting and Neurofeedback as those are the two interventions I know best.  Now, the question may come up, “Why not EMDR?” For many, EMDR is a beneficial intervention to assist in trauma resolution. However, it requires active, clinician-guided reprocessing in session, so if your goal is not to reprocess openly, then this is not your best starting point.

The key thing about all of the brain-based interventions is that they appear to be tapping into direct brain functions to help calm the nervous system, promote trauma resolution, and/or healthy formation of new habits. I tend to begin recommending a client explore one of these talk therapy alternatives when: 

Learn more about how eye position can affect how you feel and tap into the brain’s natural healing functions with Brainspotting.

Brainspotting

Learn more about how Neurofeedback can help with a wide range of symptoms by informing the brain on how it’s performing.

Neurofeedback